cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

The new PIN feature does not protect pictures and video

Just a note for anyone wondering about the protection provided by the new PIN feature - it does not protect your information.

The PIN feature protects the camera itself, which may provide some protection against theft. However, it does not protect your pictures and video.

The PIN protects information entered into the camera itself, like the date and time, or your shutter speed, or your name, if you enter it in the copyright page. But basically it doesn't provide any significant information protection, because there isn't any significant information stored in the camera itself. Your pictures and video are stored on the memory card, and the PIN doesn't protect that.

Fox example, let's say you're a doctor using the camera to document patient conditions for their medical records. You would naturally want this information to be protected. But the PIN doesn't do that. Anyone who finds the camera can simply pop the memory card into a computer and read all the pictures and video straight off the card, no PIN required.

So if you're in that situation, I would recommend that you keep your camera securely locked up in your office, or securely erase the memory card after each use.

The manual does mention this (if you can find the up-to-date manual for your camera).

The only way Canon could remedy this would be to encrypt all pictures and video. But this would be a colossal pain in the rear - you would need proprietary software to access your content every single time, and I would guess that software wouldn't be available on Linux, or Chromebooks, etc. So the status quo is probably (hopefully) how it's going to be. Just don't let the PIN give you a false sense of information security.

4 REPLIES 4

CORRECTION: the PIN does NOT provide theft protection.  Someone who steals your camera can simply press "Reset" when prompted for the PIN, and the camera will reset to factory defaults, with no PIN set.

This makes me think that the new PIN is completely useless.  Yes, it prevents a thief from seeing what shutter speed you use, or your timezone, but that's about it.

As I understand it, Canon were forced to add this feature by EU law.  This makes me think that EU lawmakers are asses.

shadowsports
Legend
Legend

Hi Ian,

My understanding was that the pin was designed to protect unauthorized access to communication parameters for wireless and USB as erasing the pin also resets the camera's settings.  This essentially leaves a clean slate.  It does seem a bit useless and overreaching on the EU's part.  I think all of us are more concerned about theft and security over an unauthorized someone seeings a saved wireless profile.  

~Rick
Bay Area - CA


~R5 C (1.0.9.1), ~R50v (1.1.1) ~RF Trinity, ~RF 100 Macro, ~RF 100~400, ~RF 100~500, ~RF 200-800 +RF 1.4x TC, BG-R10, 430EX III-RT ~DxO PhotoLab Elite ~DaVinci Resolve Studio ~ImageClass MF644Cdw/MF656Cdw ~Pixel 8 ~CarePaks Are Worth It

“EU are asses”

Charles Dickens has you covered there. 

I absolutely would NOT want my files encrypted. People lose files all the time even without encryption!

 


@shadowsports wrote:

My understanding was that the pin was designed to protect unauthorized access to communication parameters for wireless and USB as erasing the pin also resets the camera's settings. 


That could be valid.  I can't see how to get the WiFi password on my devices - the camera already seems to protect those pretty well - but I guess there could be a way, or there could be other connection-related info in there.

Still, as you say, entering a 6-digit PIN every time seems like overkill for this.

Holiday
Announcements