Good morning Melissa. I agree; nothing looks obviously wrong to me. And it is harder to explain if these are the settings you have been using all along.
One thing I have seen posted more than oince is that using print preview in the print driver can sometimes mess things up; I never use print preview, so I can't vouch for the correctness of that.
Another thing I have seen in the forum is folks think they haven't changed anything and then as the thread progresses all of a sudden it comes out that there was an OS update or software update. Not saying that's your case, but just pointing out that sometimes things happen in the background.
The other thing I do, since I sometimes use third-party papers, is use Lightroom to manage color as a standard workflow.