08-20-2024
05:13 AM
- last edited on
08-20-2024
08:29 AM
by
Danny
Hi, I am an amateur wildlife photographer, quite new to the field, I use the R7 body and RF 100-400 lens.
I have been noticing weird dark borders around background objects on some of my photos for a while and I just cannot figure out what they are.
Would someone be able to help? What is it? How is it caused? Can I somehow get rid of it, either in post-processing or at least prevent it from happening again?
On the provided example, what I mean are the dark grey sort of borderlines around the leaves in the background, clearly separating it from the sky behind. Its quite weird that when I look at the photo I somehow cannot seem to notice these lines until I zoom in and then out on the whole picture again.
Solved! Go to Solution.
08-20-2024 08:08 AM
You did not say what software you are using to view the image or what sort of screen you are viewing it on. Is the camera set to save a raw file? Is the software you are using processing a raw file while you are zooming in and back out and not finished until you have zoomed in and back out? What is your intent for this photo, documentation of a sighting or art?
What you describe sounds to me like more unsharp mask than I usually find pleasing. Too strong unsharp mask is sometimes said to create halos at boundary between light and dark. Is this a possibility?
If you place a CR3 file where others can download it, I expect someone will be able to diagnose what you are seeing.
If using Canon DPP software, you might zoom to 400% while setting unsharp mask and digital lens optimizer. For a bird photos, I avoid auto lighting optimizer and increase digital lens optimizer to make feather details more noticeable.
This is only a bird feeder photo at our house because the bird stayed hidden behind foliage in shadows before going to the feeder, but the Canon DPP processing was:
CanonVRD:Image | WorkColorSpace | sRGB |
CanonVRD:Image | RawBrightnessAdj | 0.33 |
CanonVRD:Image | WhiteBalanceAdj | Daylight |
CanonVRD:Image | WBAdjColorTemp | 5200 |
CanonVRD:Image | ColorSaturationAdj | 1 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskStrength | 2 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskFineness | 1.6 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskThreshold | 3 |
CanonVRD:Image | ShadowAdj | -2 |
CanonVRD:Image | HighlightAdj | -0.4 |
CanonVRD:Image | LuminanceNoiseReduction | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | ChrominanceNoiseReduction | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | DLOSetting | 70 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaHighlight | -0.4 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaBlackPoint | +0.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaWhitePoint | +1.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaMidPoint | +0.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | DPRAWMicroadjustBackFront | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | DPRAWMicroadjustStrength | 8 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropX | 1302 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropY | 1075 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropWidth | 1800 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropHeight | 1200 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropOriginalWidth | 5088 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropOriginalHeight | 3392 |
Part of my reasoning about the processing was that the bright colors of this bird tend to saturate and clip in bright sunlight, so I set exposure compensation to -2/3 in the camera and then brightened it as much as I could in DPP without clipping the red channel or blue channel. I darkened the shadows because they do not interest me. The DPRAW processing emphasizes the feather boundaries. I increased the input white point to get a little more dynamic range. I used digital lens optimizer at 70 and DPRAW strength at 8. In the end, I do not expect that the sharpening halos will be noticeable to most people and the there will be the appearance of sharpness.
Painted Bunting (Passerina ciris) on a birdfeeder in Norman, Oklahoma, United States on June 17, 2024 ; 400.0 mm ; 1/640 ; ISO 400 ; F/6.3 ; distance about 8 meters ; https://www.rsok.com/~jrm/2024Jun17_birds_and_cats/2024jun17_bunting_IMG_0431cs.html
08-20-2024 08:08 AM
You did not say what software you are using to view the image or what sort of screen you are viewing it on. Is the camera set to save a raw file? Is the software you are using processing a raw file while you are zooming in and back out and not finished until you have zoomed in and back out? What is your intent for this photo, documentation of a sighting or art?
What you describe sounds to me like more unsharp mask than I usually find pleasing. Too strong unsharp mask is sometimes said to create halos at boundary between light and dark. Is this a possibility?
If you place a CR3 file where others can download it, I expect someone will be able to diagnose what you are seeing.
If using Canon DPP software, you might zoom to 400% while setting unsharp mask and digital lens optimizer. For a bird photos, I avoid auto lighting optimizer and increase digital lens optimizer to make feather details more noticeable.
This is only a bird feeder photo at our house because the bird stayed hidden behind foliage in shadows before going to the feeder, but the Canon DPP processing was:
CanonVRD:Image | WorkColorSpace | sRGB |
CanonVRD:Image | RawBrightnessAdj | 0.33 |
CanonVRD:Image | WhiteBalanceAdj | Daylight |
CanonVRD:Image | WBAdjColorTemp | 5200 |
CanonVRD:Image | ColorSaturationAdj | 1 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskStrength | 2 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskFineness | 1.6 |
CanonVRD:Image | UnsharpMaskThreshold | 3 |
CanonVRD:Image | ShadowAdj | -2 |
CanonVRD:Image | HighlightAdj | -0.4 |
CanonVRD:Image | LuminanceNoiseReduction | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | ChrominanceNoiseReduction | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | DLOSetting | 70 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaHighlight | -0.4 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaBlackPoint | +0.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaWhitePoint | +1.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | GammaMidPoint | +0.000 |
CanonVRD:Image | DPRAWMicroadjustBackFront | 0 |
CanonVRD:Image | DPRAWMicroadjustStrength | 8 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropX | 1302 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropY | 1075 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropWidth | 1800 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropHeight | 1200 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropOriginalWidth | 5088 |
CanonVRD:Image | CropOriginalHeight | 3392 |
Part of my reasoning about the processing was that the bright colors of this bird tend to saturate and clip in bright sunlight, so I set exposure compensation to -2/3 in the camera and then brightened it as much as I could in DPP without clipping the red channel or blue channel. I darkened the shadows because they do not interest me. The DPRAW processing emphasizes the feather boundaries. I increased the input white point to get a little more dynamic range. I used digital lens optimizer at 70 and DPRAW strength at 8. In the end, I do not expect that the sharpening halos will be noticeable to most people and the there will be the appearance of sharpness.
Painted Bunting (Passerina ciris) on a birdfeeder in Norman, Oklahoma, United States on June 17, 2024 ; 400.0 mm ; 1/640 ; ISO 400 ; F/6.3 ; distance about 8 meters ; https://www.rsok.com/~jrm/2024Jun17_birds_and_cats/2024jun17_bunting_IMG_0431cs.html
08-20-2024 08:39 AM
Yes, I am using DPP to view the images and I shoot all of them in RAW.
What you are suggesting does make sense.
Anyway, I have now noticed that this is only visible when I view these images in basic windows image viewing software, as this software is automatically editing raw images, often resulting in things like this halo just described. It is completely fine when using DPP.
Thank you for this detailed answer and for your help, greatly!
07/01/2024: New firmware updates are available.
06/06/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS R6 Mark II - Version 1.4.0
Speedlite EL-5 - Version 1.1.0
Speedlite Transmitter ST-E10 - Version 1.1.0
04/16/2024: New firmware updates are available.
RF100-300mm F2.8 L IS USM - Version 1.0.6
RF400mm F2.8 L IS USM - Version 1.0.6
RF600mm F4 L IS USM - Version 1.0.6
RF800mm F5.6 L IS USM - Version 1.0.4
RF1200mm F8 L IS USM - Version 1.0.4
03/26/2024: New firmware updates are available.
Canon U.S.A Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part without permission is prohibited.