06-21-2013 08:43 AM
Hello everyone - I am new to Canon world and I learn as much as possible every day. I have a Canon Rebel EOS XTI with the standard 18-55 mm lens.
I would like to move on to the next step and get a better lens(s) - one for close up, portaits (higher aperture) and one for every day use. Mostly I take picture of kids and family - so it will be running and diverse lighting most of the time.
My budget is alo limited in the sense that I cannot afford most of teh 1000.00 versions 🙂
Right now I am looking for someting that will give more the f3.5 and more sharp images.
I know everyone asked around but the camera model that I have was not mentioned ... but I am sure that most of the lens should work.
Thank you.
Adrian
Solved! Go to Solution.
06-21-2013 10:35 AM
06-21-2013 09:20 AM
06-21-2013 09:40 AM
Scott thank you for your reply.
I am looking for 2 lenses indeed - so just to make sure I understood:
Thank you again.
Adrian
06-21-2013 10:05 AM - edited 06-21-2013 10:25 AM
Good advice from Scott...
Without spending a lot, you aren't going to get a zoom lens that can do it all.
If you have the original 18-55, the lens was revised and improved considerably in the later IS version (better image quality). Now it's been improved a little more with the IS STM version (quieter and more accurate AF). This is still a "kit" lens, somewhat plasticky and inexpensive.... and all versions are slower f3.5-5.6 aperture.
If you are willing to buy used, a decent, but very affordable lens you might consider for general purpose shooting is the EF 28-135 IS USM. This lens has been sold a lot in kit with 30D through 60D, sometimes even 7D. So there are lots of them around and you can pick up a lightly used copy pretty cheap... $250 or less off Craigslist (or similar) is often pretty easy to find. It's not a typical kit lens... better built (though still not "top of the line"), fast and accurate USM focus drive, close focusing so it can be used for some near macro (get macro extension tubes and use those to get even closer). It has IS, to help get steady shots, and image quality is quite good.
One drawback is that the 28-135 is an older design dating back to the days of film, and 28mm isn't wide angle on a crop sensor camera such as your XTi. A more modern model is the EF-S 18-135 IS (doesn't have USM, but the latest version has STM focus drive). Both these lenses sell for upwards of $450 US new, when bought separately from a camera. But bought in kit they often only add $200 or so to the price of the camera alone. So people offer them up pretty cheaply used.
Now, the above zooms are f3.5 to f5.6... same as the lens you presently have. But this makes them more affordable and if you complement the "walk-around" zoom with a fast prime lens or two, you might find it able to do all you need.
For portraits and low light, you might get one of the lenses Scott suggests. The 50/1.4 certainly is a good choice. The 86/1.8 is another great portrait lens. For wider view, the Canon 28/1.8 is good, too... though we often don't think of this sort of focal length for portraiture, in particular (yes, Scott is right, shooting portraits you have to be careful about getting too close with a wider lens). There is also the Sigma 30/1.4.
And, yes, for a dual purpose lens you might consider a short macro lens such as the Canon EF-S 60/2.8. The Tamron 60/2.0 macro might be even better for portraits, since it's a full stop faster. Often with portraiture you want a lens with a large aperture, to be able to blur down the background a lot, to visually separate the subject from the background. The Canon has USM focus, which probably will be faster than the Tamron in most situations. Both these lenses are on sale right now, but still are well over $400 US.
An inexpensive option is the Canon EF 50/1.8... It's little more than $100 used and is a popular entry level lens. The EF 50/1.4 is a better lens, yes, with USM, nicer background blur, considerably better build quality, richer contrast and nicer color rendition... but for the money the 50/1.8 is great for occasional portrait shots. For many poeple, it's their first introduction to faster prime lenses (as opposed to zooms, which are f2.8 at their fastest).
Now for landscape photography we often want a wider lens. There are techniques using standard and even telephoto for the puprose... but in general most people think of wide, when they are shooting landscapes. And, of the above, only the 18-135 is moderately wide angle. That's the same as your current lens, though, at it's widest. So you might just keep what you've got, for that purpose. Eventually you might want wider... and there are a number of possibilities, though most will cost $500 or more new. The Canon EF-S 10-22mm is one of the best, but is also one of the more expensive. There are also Tokina 12-24/4 and 11-16/2.8, Tamron 10-24mm, Sigma 8-16mm, and 10-20mm (two versions). There just aren't a lot of prime lenses that are truly wide angle on a crop sensor camera like yours. One fairly affordable prime that's pretty wide is the Rokinon/Samyang 14mm (also sells under Bower, Vivitar and ProOptic brand names)... but it's manual focus and manual aperture control only.
However, again, for occasional landscape shots you might just keep using what you've already got.... Try stopping it down to f8 or f11, to optimize the image quality with it.
For landscapes and possibly some other things, you might want a circular polarizer filter (cuts glare, makes blue skies bluer and enriches other colors as well), but in general don't use filters on your lenses is my recommendation. Also get a matched lens hood and use it, for each of your lenses.
Your camera is a "APS-C crop sensor model". It is fully compatible with all Canon EF and EF-S lenses. So no worries there. Any third party lens made for Canon EOS/EF mount will fit fine, too... some are designated "crop only" while others are "full frame"... but your camera can use both types just fine.
The only thing I would note if you shop for used gear, some older third party lenses have incompatible electronics, with later Canon camera models. For example, I have an older Sigma 28-75mm that works fine on EOS-3 film cameras and 10D digital, but will not focus (locks up and causes an error) on later Canon camera models. So you have to be a bit cautious about older, third party lenses. Some could be fixed by their manufacturer, but many (including the 28-75 I've got), just aren't worth it. Sigma seemed to have the most of these compatibility issues. Tamron also had a few. I haven't heard of any such issues with Tokina lenses. And there are no such compatibility issues with OEM Canon EF and EF-S lenses and your camera.
Have fun learning to use your new camera!
Alan Myers
San Jose, Calif.
"Walk softly and carry a big lens."
GEAR: 5DII, 7D(x2), 50D(x3), some other cameras, lenses and accessories.
06-21-2013 10:35 AM
06-21-2013 11:08 AM
I totally agree with Scotty on the 50/1.4. That'd be the first thing I get.
For the other stuff it's not so easy. Kids and landscapes are two very different things that require different glass. You really want a zoom (with length) for kids, no question. Landscape you want wide. I'd grab a cheap refurbished 55-250 kit lens from the Canon site for grabbing kids. Couple that with the 50 and it should give you some new things to play with. Down the road when you want to upgrade again either get a nice wide for landscape, or a decent general zoom (Sigma makes a 17-70 that covers a nice range).
06-21-2013 11:23 AM
This is great - thank you all for your feedback.
I will definetively get the 50 version and then will see - I am already looking at my next versionup for the camera.
Exciting.
06-21-2013 11:36 AM
I was going to comment on your first post:
I was really glad to see someone post that they have an older Rebel camera and they were looking to upgrade... their lenses. It's hard to not get sucked into upgrading the camera with all the new releases, but you're absolutely doing it right. Get some new glass, it'll transform your camera into something new. Coming from the 18-55 kit, you've got all kinds of room to expand. The 50 will add all new levels of sharpness and speed. A telephoto will let you track your kids as they're running around. A wide angle will definitely change how you look at things through the lens. An upgraded zoom lens can really change things compared to that kit lens. A 100mm macro will absolutely blow you away with how sharp pictures can be from what you thought was an old camera... the list goes on. It's all about the glass.
06-22-2013 04:00 AM
Some really good information on lens has been given and here is what I did this last weekend. I've filled plenty of CF cards with my XTI and still enjoy using it but have moved on to a 7D. Shooting some landscapes with the 7D and my Tamron 18x270 I was getting some great landscape shots as it's the widest lens I currently have. As i was set up for landscapes, a mule eared deer came out of nowhere and with the length of the Tamron was able to use that one lens for landscapes then a twist of the lens and I was getting some nice running deer through the pine trees. Since I have a mild selection of lens, it was nice to take care of both situations with one lens. Remember, you can rent lens and see how they fit your style prior to buying and that's been something I've done and for me it's worked just great.
06-22-2013 09:36 AM
Unfortunately fast lens, zoom and cheap don't ever go in the same sentence!
I am good with the suggestion of the 50 mm f1.4 ( effective focal length is 80 mm).
I would, however, get the 35mm f2 as a walk around lens. It's effective focal length will be 56 mm.
A 50 mm lens is considered "normal". And both of these lens are fast, way better than your f5.6 zoom.
I have three XTi's and to this day one of them rides with me in the pick-up with a 35 mm f2 on it, all the time.
It is a fantastic, go any where, easy to carry and use rig. I just love XTi's.
Forget the 40 idea.
02/20/2025: New firmware updates are available.
RF70-200mm F2.8 L IS USM Z - Version 1.0.6
RF24-105mm F2.8 L IS USM Z - Version 1.0.9
RF100-300mm F2.8 L IS USM - Version 1.0.8
RF50mm F1.4 L VCM - Version 1.0.2
RF24mm F1.4 L VCM - Version 1.0.3
01/27/2025: New firmware updates are available.
12/18/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS C300 Mark III - Version 1..0.9.1
EOS C500 Mark II - Version 1.1.3.1
12/05/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS R5 Mark II - Version 1.0.2
09/26/2024: New firmware updates are available.
Canon U.S.A Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part without permission is prohibited.