Canon Community Canon Community
 


Reply
Occasional Contributor
Posts: 15
Registered: ‎10-18-2020

extension tube question

I need to know the inside diameter of the Canon 12mm extension tube

I want to use the extension tube between my 1.4X III teleconverter and my 100mm 2.8 L macro (which are otherwise non-compatible). I have read where people are using this combo successfully BUT the protruding portion of the converter will not fit inside my old set of Kenko extension tubes so I would like to know if it will fit with the Canon before buying the new extension tube.

 

I have the R5 and the focus stacking ability makes macro work even more fabulous so I want to take full advantage of the equipment I have.

 

VIP
Posts: 11,272
Registered: ‎08-13-2015

Re: extension tube question

[ Edited ]

".....I have read where people are using this combo successfully BUT the protruding portion of the converter will not fit inside my old set of Kenko extension tubes so I would like to know if it will fit...."

 

Somehow I doubt it.  The exact dimension is probably irrelevant.  If it fits a Canon mount, then another set of tubes will most likely have a similar size and fit.  Or in your case, won't fit.

 

Maybe you should ask the people who seem to have success.  But, before you do, I think you're chasing a something down a rabbit hole.  I think that you need to better understand how the gear works.  Let's forget about the claims of others for a moment.

 

Extension tubes work by decreasing the Minimum Focusing Distnce, which comes at the cost of a dramatic reduction in the Maximum Focusing Distance.  In other words, using extension tubes means you lose the ability to focus to Inifinity, or across the average size room for that matter.  A true macro lens already has a pretty short MFD.  

 

MFD is measured from the image sensor, not the front of the lens.  It is possible that you can shorten the MFD to the point that it is inside of the barrel of the lens!  It happens to people al the time.  We frequently get posts from people asking why can't they focus on anything when using extension tubes.  The reason is because they have stacked too many and the focus plane is inside of the lens barrel.

 

Using extension tubes with a macro lens means your will rapidly approach the point of diminishing returns.  The most likely outcome is that MFD will be reduced to the point that the lens is so close that ambient light will no longer be able to adequately light up your subject.  The lens will cast a shadow over the subject, which may require you add special lighting gear.

 

Canon teleconverters are made to work with specific telephoto lenses.  I do not think any macro lenses are included in the list of compatible lenses.  An incompatible lens may cause the camera to display an error message.  Nearly all of the compatible lenses have 300mm focal lengths, or longer.  One notable exception are the 70-200 lenses.

 

If you're using a third party, budget teleconverter, then it may "work" with your macro lens, or at least seem to.  the image quality of it is probably not on par with the Canon teleconverters, and the macro lens will only magnify those differences.

 

If you're still convinced that the setup should work, then I strongly suggest that you contact the people who claimed it works.  I do not think it will work, and your experiences so far have proven that to be true.  

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Doctor told me to get out and walk, so I bought a Canon."
VIP
Posts: 13,712
Registered: ‎12-07-2012

Re: extension tube question

You know I am not a big fan of any adapter, tel-con or tubes.

 

I agree with all that is said above because sometimes the trouble you go through just to get them to work properly isn't worth it. The more you try to push adapters or extension tubes the  more difficult it becomes until, like stated above, it won't work at all.

EB
EOS 1DX and 1D Mk IV and several lenses!
Occasional Contributor
Posts: 15
Registered: ‎10-18-2020

Re: extension tube question

Thanks for the reply and sorry you had to go to all the trouble of describing the effects of teleconverters and extension tubes - I am VERY familiar with the optics etc. I also should not have said "I read" about this setup. I did read about it but also saw it being used in an online tutorial given by a professional photographer so I know it can be done. But in the tutorial, you did not see the "brand" or "model" of the converter or extension tubes I wish to find out :-) And the tutorial is several years old so not easy to get a response to a question although I have sent one of course. When it comes to "diminishing returns" - I don't know if you have done much macro work but any increase in magnification can be welcome depending on the set-up and with the 100mm lens you do have a little room to work with. So I've done lots of macro work using extension tubes in combo with my macro lens. And when I feel a need to use an extension tube with my macro the last thing I am worried about is not being able to "focus across the room" :-) Of course "lens shadow" is something everyone is aware of if they have ever tried macro work - I use a nice macro ring flash and portable light sources, reflectors etc depending on the situation to get around that issue.
In terms of lens compatibility with the extension tubes - I think the only reason for the "problem" is the physical mismatch. I only know it works with the macro-extension combo because I've seen the video of this professional using it. It works beautifully with my 100-400 L II.  Canon would have clearly had their engineers design a teleconverter for the "long lens user" market because that is certainly where the main demand is and why I have one. But the ability to combine with the macro allows for greater mag which is often what macro enthusiasts are "chasing" much of the time. Note that the inner diameter of extension tubes I already have not are perhaps just 1mm too narrow so a different model may very well be just big enough to fit so I am hopeful. Unfortunately, you can't go into most photography stores and try because so many of them don't stock extension tubes and I don't live anywhere near one of the very large camera store. I would note that "my experiences so far" are having a single brand of extension tubes - so I think it's fair to dig a little deeper than that before giving up :-)
Thanks again for your detailed response - I really do appreciate it. 

Frequent Contributor
Posts: 86
Registered: ‎09-01-2014

Re: extension tube question


@DougFraser wrote:

I need to know the inside diameter of the Canon 12mm extension tube

I want to use the extension tube between my 1.4X III teleconverter and my 100mm 2.8 L macro (which are otherwise non-compatible). I have read where people are using this combo successfully BUT the protruding portion of the converter will not fit inside my old set of Kenko extension tubes so I would like to know if it will fit with the Canon before buying the new extension tube.

 

I have the R5 and the focus stacking ability makes macro work even more fabulous so I want to take full advantage of the equipment I have.

 


I have the Canon EF 25 II extension tube and the Canon 1.4 III extender, so I just checked to see if it would fit. They attached together easily, but was very hard to take back apart, in fact, I got that sinking feeling when you know you messed up, but with a little patience and light pulling, it came apart. I wouldn't recomend this. It was like a Chinese Fingertrap Smiley Happy

 

Newton

Occasional Contributor
Posts: 15
Registered: ‎10-18-2020

Re: extension tube question

yikes - a shame they went together easily then problematic to separate. Sorry for any stress that caused you. I haven't heard back from the pro that apparently uses this combo to see what models/brands he uses. 

Frequent Contributor
Posts: 86
Registered: ‎09-01-2014

Re: extension tube question


@DougFraser wrote:

yikes - a shame they went together easily then problematic to separate. Sorry for any stress that caused you. I haven't heard back from the pro that apparently uses this combo to see what models/brands he uses. 


No problem brother. I shoot a lot of macro and have the 100mm L, so I was curious. Although I have the EF 25 II tube, I have never used it with the 100mm L macro lens. You never know, I may have cocked the devices when I was trying to disconnect them, but I don't think so. I just gently wiggled and twisted until it came apart.

Occasional Contributor
Posts: 15
Registered: ‎10-18-2020

Re: extension tube question

thanks. I guess one would certainly expect that if they do fit then putting them together and taking them apart would be equally facile. All canon products should have identical "mounts". So now I'm a bit torn. I got the 1.4X III to use with my 100-400 L II and I have done lots of macro with the 100 L so it just seemed like a nice bonus option - a little more magnification while maintaining the nice bit of distance to the subject. 

Occasional Contributor
Posts: 15
Registered: ‎10-18-2020

Re: extension tube question

FYI - I did hear back from the pro that made the video where he was using the combo and it was a Canon 12mm extension tube coupled to the Canon 1.4X III so I guess it "can work" if you are careful. At least he uses it routinely. Now I just have to confirm that AF is still available because I would want to be able to use the focus bracketing setting of the R5 to take full advantage of the investment.

VIP
Posts: 11,272
Registered: ‎08-13-2015

Re: extension tube question


@DougFraser wrote:

FYI - I did hear back from the pro that made the video where he was using the combo and it was a Canon 12mm extension tube coupled to the Canon 1.4X III so I guess it "can work" if you are careful. At least he uses it routinely. Now I just have to confirm that AF is still available because I would want to be able to use the focus bracketing setting of the R5 to take full advantage of the investment.


I would be very surprised if that work around is compatible with the focus bracketing feature in some Canon cameras.  I know the full User Guide lists a handful of compatible lenses.  You just might be limited to shooting JPG, if it even works, at all.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Doctor told me to get out and walk, so I bought a Canon."
powered by Lithium

LIKE US on Facebook FOLLOW US on Twitter WATCH US on YouTube CONNECT WITH US on Linkedin WATCH US on Vimeo FOLLOW US on Instagram SHOP CANON at the Canon Online Store
© Canon U.S.A., Inc.   |    Terms of Use   |    Privacy Statement