cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

EOS 5D Mark III - Incorrect exif data re: focal length

MNshutterbug
Enthusiast

I have a Canon 5D Mark 111 and just acquired a Canon 17-40 lens. Everything looks good and performs well but anytime I have the focal length at wider than 28mm, the exif still shows 28mm. It's correct from 28 - 40 but it's as if the camera isn't capable of registering the correct exif at anything below 28mm. I tried both jpeg and raw. Anybody else have this issue?

13 REPLIES 13

kvbarkley
Legend
Legend

Is this an RF or EF lens?

Probably a bad encoder in the lens. I suggest you see about getting it repaired

MNshutterbug
Enthusiast

It's an ef lens. I doubt for what they sell for now, that it would be worth getting it repaired. Besides, it's not affecting my photos so it's just a tad annoying, but I can live with it.

FloridaDrafter
Authority
Authority

I wouldn't think so, but it's possible the lens may need a firmware update if Canon can/will do it. That lens is 9 years older than your 5D III and from what I understand, the EF 17-40mm f/4 USM's f/w isn't user updatable.

It could also be the reason it was on the market.

Newton

MNshutterbug
Enthusiast

I'll admit, it was the best deal I could find on Ebay so that might be the reason. I rarely check exif data for focal length and the rest of the info makes sense so I'm good to go.

Hi @MNshutterbug welcome to the forums. The lens reports the focal length to the camera. The camera records the information the lens provides it. If you’re using lens correction it slightly crops in. So the entire lens image circle isn’t used. But that shouldn’t affect the focal length. Now flash photography can be affected by this. If the lens reports the wrong focal length it will affect the speedlite’s motorized zoom head. Causing over or underexposed shots. E-TTL II uses both focal length and focus distance information (if the lens has a focus distance encoder). To help calculate flash power. Note all Canon brand EF lenses have a focal length encoder. Older EF lenses lack a focus distance encoder for E-TTL II. Most lenses released after about 1990 have a focus distance encoder. Ring Type USM lenses first got these focus distance encoders. Then started to be added to Micro USM & Micro Motor lenses. Note very old Arc Form Drive (AFD) lenses released between 1987-August 1990. Never had focus distance encoders instead Canon discontinued these lenses. With newer Ring Type USM or Micro Motor versions instead. Note some AFD lenses remained in production for years. The EF 50mm F/2.5 Compact Macro was in production from December 1987 until about 2020. This was one of the longest EF lenses in production.

-Demetrius
Bodies: EOS 40D & EOS 5D Mark IV
Lenses: EF Holy Trinity, EF 50mm F/1.8 STM, EF 70-210mm F/4 & EF 85mm F/1.8 USM
Speedlites: 420EX, 470EX-AI, 550EX & 600EX II-RT

MNshutterbug
Enthusiast

It's a good thing I bought this lens for only landscape photography so no flash necessary. 

Peter
Authority
Authority

When you apply lens correction for 17 mm your software will use the profile for 25 mm. 

Peter
Authority
Authority

28 mm I mean.

MNshutterbug
Enthusiast

Peter, are you saying it could be a software issue? I have no idea what you are talking about re: lens correction but I didn't apply anything.

Announcements