03-19-2022 03:36 PM
I have a Rebel T5 and am definitely not in the position to purchase a high end body; that said, in May we are going to Alaska. Therefore, I am wondering if I purchased the RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM lens will it work with the Rebel? Obviously, I don't want to waste my money if it will not work.
Thoughts / Input would be greatly appreciated as this novice is not shy to admit I have limited knowledge and am reaching out those that know more than myself.
If it will work - do I need anything special or can I just purchase the lens?
Thank you in advance for your input!
03-19-2022 03:53 PM - edited 03-19-2022 03:53 PM
No: RF lenses do not fit, and cannot be adapted to work with DSLRs.
If you are looking to get a lens just for this trip, and will not use such a unit afterwards, I recommend renting the lens and a body. That is MUCH cheaper and you can get the best gear.
Alternatively, if you really want to own a lens then consider one of the these:
1) the EF 100-400LMkII lens - it is an excellent unit but not cheap.
2) The Sigma 150-600 Contemporary unit: excellent optics, with a wider focal range at the long end - I have one.
3) For a one unit does all, the Sigma 60-600s (sports) lens, superb optics, weather sealed, but heavy. Still, you can leave it on the body and not take it off.
03-20-2022 02:09 PM
Thank you Trevor!
You recommend Sigma 150-600 that you have ... will this work great for whale type photography? And would I need to have a add-on / converter for the camera? This is all new to me.
Steve
03-20-2022 03:55 PM - edited 03-20-2022 11:11 PM
Hi Steve: I have done a fair bit of whale watching on Canada's west coast.
I recommended the Sigma 150-600 simply because I personally know and use it, but I also respect Ernie's experience and know Tamron make some great lenses in that range too. As Ernie says, any EF or EF-S lens will work fine with your camera. You should have a great reach as that lens range allows you to track whales from a fair distance and reasonably close - from memory, the US law says you have to stay 200m away from them, Canada 100m, but that doesn't stop the whales coming to you - they are intelligent and curious creatures. You don't need an extender or teleconverter. You will need a few spare batteries and cards though...
Much will depend on the weather, and the Sigma is fairly weather resistant and likely so is the Tamron, however your camera is not, so get a wet weather bag to cover the camera if things turn to custard and you are out in a RIB. Even a clean bread bag will do at a pinch.
PREPARATION:
Camera Settings: When you are out there, set your camera to servo autofocus and high-speed continuous - you should have your manual to hand before you go and browse through the information, and look at You Tube videos on settings for photographing wildlife.
Practice with whatever lens you have and if you cannot hold it for a while, do some physical training: generally, unless you are on a very big boat, you can't use a tripod and maybe not even a monopod on a small boat for H&S reasons: certainly not on a RIB (Rigid Inflatable Boat) - see one below to get my point. Try to get on a bigger, cabin cruiser type boat if possible, not just for the room but they often have an upper deck to give you more viewing and shooting options.
I do weights regularly so I can hold my gear steady without fatigue so I don't have to depend on a support.
Study whale behaviour - not only will it help you get better photos, but you will enjoy the experience more. Lots of videos on whales: David Attenborough's videos from his shows are always good.
Some photos I took when I was whale-watching in Victoria, BC:
Whales approach our RIB in hunting mode. What they do is line up and charge their prey (usually seals basking on ice flows) and dive just under the boat, using their bodies to create a big wave that will wash their prey into the sea. They aren't stupid, they know boats behave differently from ice and just roll with it, so they seem to do it for fun or practice. When several did it to our boat they bobbed up on the other side and looked at us as if to say: 'How's that then?" The boats just bob a bit, but you have to be careful not to stand and lose your balance, and either fall in or drop your camera in the drink. Taken at 235mm
Taken at 300mm, this shot shows a pod of whales in almost each step of sounding
There is also other wildlife to be seen, so be ready!
03-21-2022 04:23 PM
Thank you so much for sharing!
The photos are awesome representation of the lens!!
Also, thank you for your input to what Ernie wrote too.
Steve
03-20-2022 10:38 AM
"2) The Sigma 150-600 Contemporary unit:"
Further, any of the 150-600mm super zooms will work nicely for you. Sigma C, Sigma S, Tamron, Tamron G2. Even an older used 150-500mm is a good choice if you find a good one. Test before you buy and personally I would not want the Sigma S on a Rebel T5 but it will fit and do a nice job.
03-20-2022 10:51 AM
"RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM lens"
For clarity you are looking for a lens with EF or EF-S in its name if you go Canon. Not RF or M.
03-20-2022 02:06 PM
Thank you for reply and questions back.... 🙂
I am just looking at zoom type lens that will work with my Rebel 5T that is 100mm to 500mm. On the Rebel there is a white dot and red dot for different types of lens. I have a wide angle that uses RED dot while the original lens that came with the camera uses the white dot.
We will be hopefully being seeing whales and other sea wildlife and am looking for lens.
03-20-2022 04:45 PM
The lenses that Ernie and I are suggesting will align via the Red Dot. The red dot is to align EF lenses (those designed to work for full-frame cameras), while the white dot is to align the connection for EF-S lenses (those designed specifically for crop-sensor bodies like yours). Most likely the Sigma and Tamron lenses will have white dots, but that is because they don't use Canon's colour convention. They will align to the red dot on your camera to attach as they are designed for FF and crop bodies.
03-20-2022 03:33 PM
Best go is Sigma C or Tamron G2 150-600mm super zoom go with ever one is cheaper. They are basically the same IQ wise. Also a sturdy tripod.
12/18/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS C300 Mark III - Version 1..0.9.1
EOS C500 Mark II - Version 1.1.3.1
12/05/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS R5 Mark II - Version 1.0.2
09/26/2024: New firmware updates are available.
EOS R6 Mark II - Version 1.5.0
Canon U.S.A Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part without permission is prohibited.