Fairy Tale Rose - which vignette do you prefer?

[Illumined]

I was playing around with my dream filter and got this cool shot of a rose in front of my house. I can't decide which vignette looks better though. What do you think?

50mm, f1.8, 1/500, ISO 400

[JCin]

The darker vignette! White usually looks like a feather crop, the darker one brings the eye to the subject. I like that dark vignette.