05-29-2015 08:05 PM
Looking to purchase a fast lens for sports with limited resources. Can someone with knowledge gave me a comparison of the Canon 70-200mm f/2.8L IS USM II with Tamron SP 70-200mm f/2.8 DI VC USD and Sigma APO 70-200mm f/2.8 EX DG OS HSM. Would welcome any other recommendations.
05-29-2015 09:34 PM
Hopefully EB will read your thread & join in but for now see
05-29-2015 09:35 PM
05-30-2015 11:19 AM
"Unless there is someone on here who works at a camera store or a lens rental place it will be hard to find folks who know all 3"
Hmmm, I don't own a camera store but I do have all three. I also have all three of the 24-70mm f2.8's. I don't think I am too hard to find either!
Anyway my assessment of the three as asked is. First, neither the Tammy or Siggy is a Canon EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM Lens. If you expect it t be, save your money for awhile longer and get the real deal. However, for about a grand less, you can get one of the others and they are very good indeed.
Most people do not need the extreme build of a Canon "L" lens and that is the biggest factor where the Tamron and Sigma fall short. So in short, take care of it, if you get one. The is a lot of plastic.
I would bet the average shooter, that is not a pixel peeper, wil be able to tell if a photo was taken by which lens.
As Scotty pointed out they probably do focus somewhat slower but again we are talking very little difference.
I think the decission of which, the Sigma or the Tamron, is really a moot point. They are very similar and each has a few better points and a few not as 'better' points. I also would warn against buying one used. If you are into this area of expense, you are already saving approx. a grand so buy new!
Oh, BTW, if you decide on the Tammy make sure you get the Tamron SP 70-200mm f/2.8 Di VC USD Zoom Lens, MFR # AFA009C-700. It must have these letters in its name. The A009 is the latest version as there are some lesser models and you don't want one of them. I think there is ony one version of the Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 EX DG APO OS HSM but there are its letters.
And, BTW 2.0, make sure you get the USA versions as they have a 6 year warranty. I never used it myself but a couple friends have and they do honor their stuff.........................................................so far!
05-30-2015 11:29 AM
BTW 3.0, if you do want a 24-70mm f2.8, there is considerable difference. The order is, Canon followed by the Tamron and lastly the Siggy. In this case none of these are up to the Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8L II USM Lens.
The Tammy is closest again, is much cheaper and has stablization.
The Sigma is shorter and lighter but not as good IQ and no IS. It is also the cheapest of the three. And again for the average shooter probably fine.
05-30-2015 02:06 PM
05-30-2015 04:26 PM
I am a huge fan of Tony Northrup and I have seen that vid. Actually it caused a interesting conversation between myself and Tom (astronomy buddy) about lenses. Tom knows more about lenses than anybody I know.
We both think the video has a couple misques or at least not explained well in spots. Otherwise it is pretty good and I recommend folks watcht it.
IMHO, focus breathing is a none issue. Most people are not even aware it exists. One issue Tony misses is the Nikkor is probably not a true 200mm lens at 200mm! I don't know what it is but it is something less. Most likely 185mm or so. As a matter of fact, I have never seen a lens that measures what the manufactuer claims it is. They are all always short.
Want a test ? Take your 70-200mm and set it to 135mm. Now look through it and a prime 135mm lens. Do you see the same FOV? Probably not. Actually not only because of the focal length disparity but the markings a not very accurate.
Focal lengths are rounded to the closest standard focal length. You ever seen a 83-187mm zoom lens? The manufacturer probably marketed it and sold it as a 80-200mm. Even the EXIF data will report the focal length as 200mm when the actual focal length was 187mm. The lens has a chip that is programmed by the manufacturer to report "200mm" when set at the maximum focal length.
Focus breathing is like crop factor. It just doesn't matter. If folks thought of the 'angle of view' of a lens instead of focal length, things would be far easier. But the focal length is what is printed on every lens so that is what we use.
All lenses move when you focus them. This changes the focal length. And it does so on either end, the wide side and the tele side. Not solely the long end. It is what it is.
05-30-2015 07:10 PM
05-30-2015 07:34 PM
No Scott, I am just a complete nut! Miss Elizabeth reminds me almost every day and I have come to believe her.
I love to get lenses, try them, test them and just play with them. When I was working I had the Canon and later I got the II version which I still have. The older one has been passed on.
I usually sell on most of what I buy but these three are all keepers. Some I decide or find out they aren't worth keeping or I have no use for them at all. (After playing around with them.)
05-30-2015 08:01 PM
Thanks for all your comments. Right after I posted my enquiry, I saw the reference under 'Lens Upgrade' and a comparison of all three lenses by Bryan Carnathan. Now I am deciding between the Canon or the Tamron. Thanks.
05/31/2023: New firmware updates are available.
EOS R6 Mark II - Version 1.1.2
05/18/2023: New firmware updates are available.
EOS Rebel T100 - Version 1.1.0
EOS 5D Mark IV - Version 1.4.0
EOS 6D Mark II - Version 1.2.0
PowerShot Elph 360HS - Version 220.127.116.11
PowerShot SX420 IS - Version 18.104.22.168
PowerShot 620 HS - Version 22.214.171.124
PowerShot SX720 HS - Version 126.96.36.199
PowerShot G1X Mark III - Version 188.8.131.52
PowerShot G7X Mark II - Version 184.108.40.206
PowerShot G9X Mark II - Version 220.127.116.11
04/20/2023: New firmware version 1.4.1 is available for EOS R3
03/30/2023: New firmware updates are available.
EOS 1DX Mark III- Version 1.7.1
Speedlite EL-1 - Version 1.0.2
03/30/2023: Product Advisory for EF50 F1.2 L USM
03/30/2023: Product Advisory for EOS R10
2/07/2023: New product announcements!EOS R8 EOS R50RF-S55-210mm F5-7.1 IS STMRF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STMRF15-30mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM
Canon U.S.A Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part without permission is prohibited.