topic Re: IS on R5 grayed out with RF70-200 lens in EOS DSLR & Mirrorless Cameras

IS on R5 grayed out with RF70-200 lens

DaBrownCO — Sat, 25 Dec 2021 03:10:28 GMT

In looking through the forum, it seems IBIS is not available if the lens has IS option. Can someone explain why this may be the case?

Re: IS on R5 grayed out with RF70-200 lens

jaewoosong — Sat, 25 Dec 2021 04:56:06 GMT

I see the same for my RF24-70F2.8 IS

any lens with mechanical IS switch will grey out the IS option in the menu. The switch acts as the overall off/on switch. The menu based IS is for lenses like a prime lense that are not lens stabilized so the IS menu is to turn off the IBIS.

I believe that if you have IS on lens, either both lens/IBIS is on or both are off.

Re: IS on R5 grayed out with RF70-200 lens

AtticusLake — Sat, 25 Dec 2021 09:05:29 GMT

Just to second that. From what I've heard, with an IS lens, the IBIS does work, but it's not separately switchable. The switch on the lens controls both.

Which seems weird, but I can imagine that doing IS would be very tricky when there are two separate mechanisms (the lens and IBIS) both fighting to stabilise the image; unless they're very carefuly co-ordinated. I guess that Canon has decided to focus on that part. Which is fine by me.

Re: IS on R5 grayed out with RF70-200 lens

DaBrownCO — Sat, 25 Dec 2021 15:19:13 GMT

Thanks Atticus and Jaewoo! Your info is very helpful.

Atticus, that's what my assumption too is about the two mechanisms fighting each other. It makes perfect sense.

JaeWoo, it is good to know that when I turn IS off on the lens, it is off everywhere. That means I don't need to go into the menu when I put the camera on a tripod.