topic Re: Canon 1DX Mk II Problems: Silent Shutter. Which is the difference? in EOS DSLR & Mirrorless Cameras

Canon 1DX Mk II Problems: Silent Shutter. Which is the difference?

JohnTh — Wed, 06 Jul 2016 06:54:04 GMT

Hi,

On Canon 1DX Mk II we have the following modes:

1. Single Image

2. Single Image Silent Mode

Between the two above one can distinguish a certain difference because it is clear that in the 2nd case the mirror is released when the photog released the shutter button. I don't know how quieter is but, anyway, the separation between raising and lowering the mirror can make a (small) difference.

However we have:

3. Burst mode (normal = loud)

4. Burst mode Silent - L(ow rate)

5. Burst mode Silent - H(ight rate)

Which are the differences in sound between these modes?

Isn't supposed that cases 4 & 5 to be quieter with the case 4 being quietest from all?

Sorry, but I can't distinguish any difference. On 5D3 the difference was noticeable. Can't we have the same on 1DX2?

TIA

Re: Canon 1DX Mk II Problems: Silent Shutter. Which is the difference?

Waddizzle — Wed, 06 Jul 2016 12:17:54 GMT

"Which are the differences in sound between these modes?"

You seem to have listed the differences. No doubt the frame rate varies from fastest to slowest between those modes.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Isn't supposed that cases 4 & 5 to be quieter with the case 4 being quietest from all?"

I would think taking stills in quiet mode would make the least noise. Use a decibel meter to confirm/deny your findings.

Re: Canon 1DX Mk II Problems: Silent Shutter. Which is the difference?

ebiggs1 — Wed, 06 Jul 2016 14:14:58 GMT

When I have used the "silent" feature of a 1 series, I think it matters only because you can move the camera to a less obtrusive place. Say a quite church where the priest doesn't really like the idea pf photographers in the firs place, you can shoot and then drop the camera by your side. Release the shutter. It is less noticeable at least if not actually less noisy.

Other than that it is a useless feature.

Re: Canon 1DX Mk II Problems: Silent Shutter. Which is the difference?

JohnTh — Thu, 07 Jul 2016 06:52:19 GMT

@Waddizzle wrote:
"Which are the differences in sound between these modes?"

You seem to have listed the differences. No doubt the frame rate varies from fastest to slowest between those modes.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Isn't supposed that cases 4 & 5 to be quieter with the case 4 being quietest from all?"

I would think taking stills in quiet mode would make the least noise. Use a decibel meter to confirm/deny your findings.

:-)))))

Exactly this is the gist of my message: taking stills in quiet mode does not make the least noise, unfortunatelly. 🙂 (in fact, it takes almost the same noise, just softer).

Believe me I tried & know from a loooong (and sometimes bitter) experience. I shoot mainly in churches. See my portfolio at http://asceticexperience.com

The only difference is (aside of frame rate which isn't the topic of this thread) in the single shot mode, like I stated in my OP and @ebiggs1 notticed it.