topic Re: EF 70-300mm, EF M 18-150mm or EF M 55-200mm for Canon EOS M50? in EF & RF Lenses

EF 70-300mm, EF M 18-150mm or EF M 55-200mm for Canon EOS M50?

Charliecharles — Sat, 02 Feb 2019 10:28:25 GMT

I'm interested in having a zoom lens for my mirrorless. I'm at the moment leaning toward the 18-150 which could be a good all around lens.

That said the 300mm offer a superior zoom capability but is initially for full frame.

Speed are all about the same, the stabilization probably also.

What's your thoughts on IQ and usability of these lenses ?

Re: EF 70-300mm, EF M 18-150mm or EF M 55-200mm for Canon EOS M50?

Waddizzle — Sat, 02 Feb 2019 19:34:14 GMT

@Charliecharles wrote:
I'm interested in having a zoom lens for my mirrorless. I'm at the moment leaning toward the 18-150 which could be a good all around lens.
That said the 300mm offer a superior zoom capability but is initially for full frame.
Speed are all about the same, the stabilization probably also.
What's your thoughts on IQ and usability of these lenses ?

What other lenses do you have? It is better to expand your range of focal lengths, than it is to duplicate what you already have.

I recommend sticking with the native mount lenses, whenever possible. The EF-M mount lenses will have a lower current draw than the EF mount lenses. Also, Canon’s EF-M mount lenses are much newer designs than the majority of their EF mount lenses, which usually means sharper images.

The 18-150mm lens has a zoom ratio, longest FL to shortest FL that is roughly 6:1, which is little on the too wide side. The best zoom lenses have zoom ratios of 4:1, or less. But, the 18-150mm is fairly recent design, so that decade old rule of thumb could probably be stretched a bit to include 6:1.

I own the M3, and use the EF-M 22mm f/2 STM, which I love. It is fast. Most of Canon’s EF-M zoom lenses have all been just a bit too slow at the long end of their focal range, f/6.3. The lenses would work great outdoors, but not as well indoors without a flash. I can shoot with my 22mm indoors without too much trouble.

Re: EF 70-300mm, EF M 18-150mm or EF M 55-200mm for Canon EOS M50?

Tronhard — Mon, 04 Feb 2019 18:26:25 GMT

I have an M5 along with the 18-150 lens as its standard walk around lens. I also have the 11-22, 18-55 (when I got the original M body) and the 55-200. I agree with Waddizzle that they are not the fastest lenses but that is an issue depending on what you are going to shoot. I do most of my shooting outdoors and often in reasonable light for scenic and the occasional wildlife. I have other DSLRs for serious wildlife shooting.

If you wanted to go for an EF lens you will have to add the adaptor as well as the lens itself, which adds quite a lot of bulk and weight at the front end of a very small body - throwing the unit out of balance IMHO. If you are serious about using a telephoto lens I would hope you shoot using the viewfinder rather than the rear LCD for stabililty.